Climate Reporting in the US: Federal Deadlock at the SEC and California’s Pioneering Law
The anti-ESG backlash, litigation and the state climate package SB 253 and SB 261.
The United States is currently the most polarised market for ESG reporting. At federal level, the SEC’s rules have been put on hold in an unprecedented way as a result of the “anti-ESG backlash”, and individual states have taken matters into their own hands. California, with its Climate Accountability package (SB 253 and SB 261), has become the real leader. In this article I examine the causes of the federal regulatory paralysis and the practical effects of the Californian rules, which also reach international groups doing business in that state.
|
Federal level The SEC’s rules have been put on hold as a result of the “anti-ESG backlash”. |
California Climate Accountability package (SB 253 and SB 261). |
Sustainability reporting in the United States
While Asia shows a strong trend towards interoperability, even towards unified sustainability reporting standards, the situation in the United States clearly runs against the direction of global harmonisation. Two things contribute to this: the deep regulatory fragmentation typical of the American market, and the current direction of US policy.
Federal regulation: the SEC’s attempt to standardise climate disclosures
On 6 March 2024 the US Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) adopted its rule on climate-related disclosures (The Enhancement and Standardization of Climate-Related Disclosures for Investors). Substantively based on the TCFD framework and the GHG Protocol, the rule was meant to be the federal foundation for reporting climate-related risks. Even while it was being prepared, political pressure led the SEC to soften its requirements compared with the 2022 proposal: the final version dropped the duty to report emissions across the whole value chain (Scope 3), and made the disclosure of Scope 1 and 2 emissions depend on materiality. The political, legal and economic resistance to using environmental, social and governance criteria in investment processes and reporting is known as the “anti-ESG backlash”. It was this resistance that first halted the rule’s implementation and then led the SEC to stop defending it.
The anti-ESG movement and its effect on federal regulation
The US fossil fuel industry objected to the growing weight of sustainability criteria in the investment strategies of the largest asset managers. Republican politicians then amplified that opposition.
Faced with a large number of challenges to the rule, on 4 April 2024 the SEC issued a formal order staying its application until the end of judicial review. The challenges were filed in several federal courts of appeals by a coalition of states and private parties who questioned the rule’s legality. They argued that the SEC had exceeded the powers Congress gave it in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, which authorises it only to require disclosures that are necessary or appropriate for the proper protection of investors and to ensure fair dealing, and that it had breached the rulemaking procedure set out in the Administrative Procedure Act. Petitions were filed in the Second, Fifth, Sixth, Eighth and Eleventh Circuits. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2112(a)(3), the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation consolidated the challenges and sent them to the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.
On 27 March 2025 the SEC voted by majority to stop defending the 6 March 2024 rule in the proceedings before the Eighth Circuit (Iowa v. SEC, No. 24-1522). The court put the case in abeyance and in September 2025 indicated that it would stay there until the SEC either reconsiders the rule through notice-and-comment procedure or resumes its defence. In May 2026 the SEC told the court it would reconsider the rule, and on 29 May 2026 it proposed rescinding it in full. The comment period closed on 3 August 2026.
The SEC climate rule
Dates stated in this article. The rule never took effect.
-
6 March 2024
Rule adopted
The Enhancement and Standardization of Climate-Related Disclosures for Investors. Scope 3 was dropped. Scope 1 and 2 depend on materiality
-
4 April 2024
Stayed
Formal order staying application until the end of judicial review. Challenges went to the Eighth Circuit
-
27 March 2025
Defence withdrawn
The SEC voted to stop defending the rule in Iowa v. SEC, No. 24-1522
-
September 2025
Case in abeyance
The court indicated the case would stay there until the SEC reconsiders the rule or resumes its defence
-
29 May 2026
Rescission proposed
The SEC proposed rescinding the rule in full. The comment period closed on 3 August 2026
State regulation: California’s Climate Accountability package
In October 2023, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed two key state laws: SB 253, the Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act, which requires greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reporting in line with the GHG Protocol, and SB 261, Greenhouse gases: climate-related financial risk, which requires a report on climate-related financial risks in line with the TCFD recommendations (reporting under IFRS S2 is also accepted). Together the two laws make up the California Climate Accountability package (the “CCAP”).
|
SB 253 Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act. Greenhouse gas emissions reporting in line with the GHG Protocol. |
SB 261 Greenhouse gases: climate-related financial risk. A report in line with the TCFD recommendations. Reporting under IFRS S2 is also accepted. |
Entities covered by the California Climate Accountability package
The CCAP covers thousands of public and private entities in the United States, including subsidiaries of entities headquartered outside the US. SB 253 requires reporting on all three scopes of the carbon footprint from entities with annual revenue above USD 1 billion that do business in California. Under SB 261, the duty to report climate-related financial risks applies to entities with annual revenue above USD 500 million that also do business in California.
Who is covered in California
above USD 1 billion SB 253. All three scopes of the carbon footprint. Entities that do business in California
above USD 500 million SB 261. Climate-related financial risks. Entities that do business in California
Thresholds stated in this article. Public and private entities are covered, including subsidiaries of entities headquartered outside the US.
Subject-matter scope of the California Climate Accountability package
SB 253 and SB 261 are framework laws: the state legislature set the basic scope of the reporting duties and left methodology, the form of disclosures, detailed timetables and assurance rules to implementing regulations issued by the California Air Resources Board (“CARB”), the state agency responsible for air quality and for controlling greenhouse gas emissions.
Entities covered by SB 253 must disclose their greenhouse gas emissions every year: in 2026 for Scopes 1 and 2 only (for financial year 2025), and from 2027 for Scope 3 as well. CARB’s implementing regulation was approved in October 2026, and the first Scope 1 and 2 reports are due by 10 November 2026, after the original August deadline was pushed back. Scope 3 does not apply in the first cycle, and CARB has announced that from 2027 it will initially cover selected categories (five of fifteen). External assurance is not required in the first cycle; under CARB’s rules, from 2027 it will take the form of limited assurance of Scope 1 and 2 emissions, with reasonable assurance by 2030.
Entities with revenue above USD 500 million were to publish a climate-related financial risk report under SB 261 every two years, starting on 1 January 2026. That obligation is currently suspended by a court order, discussed in section 5.2.3.
In an enforcement notice of December 2024, CARB announced a lenient approach to enforcing SB 253 in the first reporting cycle: it will not take punitive action against entities that, in good faith and on the basis of available data, disclose incomplete Scope 1 and 2 emissions. For Scope 3, the legislature built in a safe harbour: reporting entities are not liable for inaccuracies or gaps in the data as long as the disclosures are made in good faith and on the best information available. This reflects how hard it is to obtain and verify information from business partners.
A characteristic feature of SB 253 is that it has no materiality threshold.
This clearly sets the Californian model apart from the ISSB standards, under which GHG emissions must be disclosed to the extent that climate risks and opportunities are material to enterprise value (financial materiality). It also differs from the ESRS, which rest on double materiality: under the original wording of the standards there was a presumption that emissions are material, so an undertaking that considered climate immaterial had to explain in detail why. That made the disclosure practically always mandatory, though formally it remained part of the materiality assessment.
The effect of the anti-ESG movement on sustainability regulation in California
In November 2025 the US Chamber of Commerce and other business organisations sought a temporary stay on enforcement of SB 253 and SB 261, arguing that they violate the free speech guaranteed by the First Amendment by forcing companies to speak on the deeply controversial subject of climate change. On 18 November 2025 the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals suspended enforcement of SB 261 pending appeal, leaving SB 253 in force. CARB said it would not enforce SB 261 until the case is decided and would set a new reporting date after the ruling. The Ninth Circuit heard the case in January 2026, and as far as I am aware no ruling on the merits has yet been issued. Until then SB 261 is effectively optional, while SB 253 enters its first reporting cycle.
California’s two laws
Dates stated in this article. SB 261 is suspended. SB 253 is in its first reporting cycle.
-
October 2023
Laws signed
Governor Gavin Newsom signed SB 253 and SB 261
-
December 2024
Lenient first cycle
CARB will not take punitive action for incomplete Scope 1 and 2 disclosures made in good faith
-
18 November 2025
SB 261 suspended
The Ninth Circuit suspended enforcement of SB 261 pending appeal and left SB 253 in force
-
1 January 2026
SB 261 start date
Climate-related financial risk reports were to begin, every two years. The obligation is suspended
-
10 November 2026
First SB 253 reports
Scope 1 and 2 for financial year 2025. Scope 3 does not apply in the first cycle
-
From 2027
Scope 3 and assurance
Scope 3 begins, initially five of fifteen categories. Limited assurance of Scope 1 and 2. Reasonable assurance by 2030
It remains to be seen whether the current political changes in the United States will strengthen the position of sustainability reporting.
Key takeaway
The American experience shows how strongly political and legal disputes shape climate reporting. With the SEC’s federal rules put on hold, the regulatory burden has shifted to the level of individual states. California’s requirements (SB 253) show, however, that companies operating globally will not escape the duty to count their carbon footprint, even if its reach into the value chain is being introduced cautiously. In the final article we compare all of these systems and ask how likely they are to converge globally.